Skip menuLog in to Nordea NetbankLog in to Nordea Business

Hyvä tarina vai hyvä bisnes? Näin tunnistat laatuyhtiön | Femme x Nordea Salkunhaltijat 08

Oops! Accept Marketing cookies to view contents like this from Nordea

Kun ymmärrät, miten yhtiö tekee rahaa, seuraava askel on arvioida liiketoiminnan laatua. Tähän liittyen on hyvä pohtia, onko kyseessä hyvä tarina vai todellinen laatubisnes! Tässä Femmen ja Nordean yhteistyöjaksossa Iman Chellaf Nordealta ja Marianne Palmu Inderesiltä avaavat muun muassa sitä, miten sijoittaja voi tarkastella yhtiön laatua, kilpailuasemaa ja tulevaisuuden edellytyksiä sekä erottaa lupaukset teoista.

A great story, but where are the receipts?

The stock market is full of companies with big ambitions. Some are still in the early stages, rich in vision but with little in the way of a proven track record. These are often referred to as “story stocks”. Others are long-established, high-quality businesses that have demonstrated their strengths over many years. 

Much like in dating, a good story can be highly appealing in investing too. Big plans, confident presentation and an exciting vision of the future can make a company seem attractive very quickly. But before you get carried away, it’s worth asking yourself: is there evidence to back it all up?

When the vision sounds like science fiction

SpaceX is a good example of a story stock, where investors place significant value on future potential. The company’s current business remains relatively small, and a large part of the overall operations is still unprofitable. Investors do not assess the company solely on the basis of today’s figures. More importantly, they focus on what the business could become in the future.

The SpaceX story includes many ideas that, not long ago, might have sounded like science fiction: satellite internet services, space-based operations and even plans to colonise Mars. For some companies, future ambitions such as these play a much larger role than their current track record. In such cases, investors need to take a particularly close look at how realistic the growth opportunities are and how likely they are to develop into profitable businesses.

A compelling story does not necessarily mean a poor business

It would be a mistake to assume that story stocks are automatically bad investments. They can also represent genuinely promising businesses. Starlink, SpaceX’s satellite internet service, for example, has grown rapidly and is expected to become a significant part of the company’s future.

The key point is that some story stocks are built more on promises than on proven results. That is why it’s important to consider whether a company’s value is based primarily on an established business or on what investors expect it to achieve in the future.

A quality business delivers on its promises

Then there are companies that do more than just make promises. They have a proven track record of delivering results. These listed companies are well-established, high-quality businesses that have demonstrated their ability to perform time and again. 

Microsoft, for example, can be considered a quality company because it has achieved profitable growth for many years while strengthening its position across multiple markets. Its success is built not only on future promises but also on a strong track record.

When assessing the quality of a company, it is important to look at both the promises and the proof. Ask yourself: has management consistently delivered on its targets, or do the targets keep changing?

Management and the numbers reveal the truth

When evaluating a company’s quality, it makes sense to start with its management team. After all, management plays a crucial role in determining whether a compelling story is also reflected in actions and results.

In practice, you can assess a company’s quality by considering questions such as:

  • Does management have a track record of delivering on its promises?
  • Does management own shares in the company?
  • Has the company delivered profitable growth and strong return on equity over a long period without taking on excessive debt?
  • Does the company operate in a growing market where it has a competitive advantage?
  • Is the company managed responsibly with a long-term perspective?

If the strategy seems to change every year to reflect the latest buzzwords, it is worth pausing to consider what that might say about the business.

When management has skin in the game

Management ownership and incentives matter too. When executives hold a meaningful stake in the company, their interests are often more closely aligned with those of other shareholders. 

It is also worth taking a closer look at incentive structures. Is management rewarded solely for growing revenue, or are metrics such as return on equity also taken into account? The distinction is important because growth is not always profitable. The ideal situation is one where management is rewarded for creating sustainable long-term value.

The numbers reveal quality

A quality company should also stand out in the numbers. You don’t need to be a financial analyst to understand the basics.

Key indicators of profitability include the net profit margin, which measures profit relative to revenue, and return on equity (ROE). Rather than focusing on a single year, it is better to assess whether the company has delivered profitable growth consistently over time. These figures are usually easy to find online.

It is also helpful to compare key figures with those of companies in the same industry, as typical revenue levels vary from sector to sector. Be sure to examine the company’s level of debt as well. While a higher level of debt can boost return on equity, it can also increase risk.

A high return on equity is often a sign of a high-quality business. Strong profitability can also indicate that the company has competitive advantages, which we discussed in the previous section.

The role of the market in a company’s success

A company’s quality is not determined solely by what it does but also by the market in which it operates. Is the market growing or shrinking? How intense is the competition?

Let’s take an example. Lift manufacturer KONE operates in a growing market, driven by ongoing urbanisation around the world and rising demand for lifts. At the same time, it has a relatively limited number of major competitors. From an investor’s perspective, that can be an attractive combination. Market dynamics can help underpin a company’s success, but it’s important to consider them alongside the company’s other strengths and the valuation of its shares.

Market share is a sign of demand

Another important metric is market share. It indicates whether there is genuine demand for a company’s products. Take Apple, for example. The company holds a strong position in the global smartphone market and is one of the most profitable businesses in the industry. There is little doubt that Apple is a quality company.

Sustainability as part of quality

Finally, it’s worth considering sustainability. Companies that neglect responsible business practices are more likely to find themselves in the headlines for the wrong reasons.

Quality is not just about strong financial results. It’s also about running a business with a responsible, sustainable and long-term approach.

The numbers behind the story

A good rule of thumb is that a company’s story must be backed up by numbers. That’s a hallmark of quality.

A compelling story can spark your interest, and there’s nothing wrong with that. But a quality business proves over time that there’s substance behind the narrative. That’s why it’s important to look at not only the vision but also the track record. What does the company promise? What has it already achieved? And is that progress reflected in growth, profitability and value creation for shareholders?

Keep these points in mind when assessing a company

The next time you come across a company that interests you, ask yourself these three questions:

  • Is the management team trustworthy and credible? 
  • Is quality reflected in sustained, profitable growth and healthy finances? 
  • Does the company have a genuine competitive advantage in its market?

If the answer to these questions is yes, you have probably found a quality company. If the answers are unclear or you see more promises than proof, you may be looking at a great story rather than a great business. And that’s okay too. It’s better to learn how to recognise the difference before investing in a company to avoid surprises later.

Next up: a good company, but at what price?

In the next lesson, we move beyond first impressions and turn our attention to the price tag. No matter how impressive a company may seem, it’s worth asking whether the share price is justified. When is a good company a good buying opportunity and when are expectations already too high?

Important information about investing

This is an advertisement. The information provided on this website is intended as general product information only and does not constitute investment advice or recommendations. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. The value of investment products may increase or decrease due to market movements, and it is not certain that you will get back the entire amount you invested. Before making any investment decisions, you should read the relevant prospectus and key investor information documents for more details about the investment product.

Need help?

Personal customers